Skip to content

American Gold Eagle AU58 Sold Prices

The median sold price for American Gold Eagle AU58 is $1,700. Most sell between $800 and $4,250, based on 28 eBay sold listings.

Median Price
The middle price when all sales are sorted. Best represents what most buyers pay.
$1,700
Avg Price
The mean of the middle 80% of sold prices. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$2,136
Most Sell For
80% of sales fall within this range. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$800 – $4,250
10th–90th percentile
Total Sales
28

Price History

$3,456$1,072
$2,294
2026-01
7 sales
$3,456
2026-02
7 sales
$1,648
2026-03
4 sales
$2,276
2026-04
7 sales
$1,072
2026-05
3 sales
2026-012026-05
Monthly average price history
MonthAverage priceSales
2026-01$2,2947
2026-02$3,4567
2026-03$1,6484
2026-04$2,2767
2026-05$1,0723

Price Distribution

<$800
2 sales
$800–$1.3k
6 sales
$1.3k–$1.8k
6 sales
$2.3k–$2.8k
5 sales
$2.8k–$3.3k
2 sales
$3.3k–$3.8k
2 sales
$3.8k–$4.3k
1 sales
>$4.3k
4 sales
<$800$2.3k–$2.8k>$4.3k
Price distribution by bucket
Price rangeSales
<$8002
$800–$1.3k6
$1.3k–$1.8k6
$1.8k–$2.3k0
$2.3k–$2.8k5
$2.8k–$3.3k2
$3.3k–$3.8k2
$3.8k–$4.3k1
>$4.3k4

Sales

Showing 1–25 of 28

Sort:
NewestPrice HighPrice LowOldest
TitlePrice
ITALY - SARDINIA , GOLD 20 LIRE (EAGLE) 1820-L PCGS AU 58 , RARE7
$1,700
1925 D Indian Gold Quarter Eagle $2.50 Coin PCGS graded AU58!!!
$800
1925 D Indian Gold Quarter Eagle $2.50 Coin PCGS graded AU58 Beautiful Coin!
$715
1845-D Dahlonega GA $5 gold half eagle. ICG AU58 details, whizzed. #m3d101
$2,406
1880 Gold $5 Liberty Head Half-Eagle - With Motto; PCGS AU58; Philadelphia Mint
$1,164
1880 S $10 Liberty U.S. GOLD EAGLE COIN PCGS AU58
$3,260
1908 GOLD USA $5 DOLLAR LIBERTY HEAD HALF EAGLE COIN NGC AU58
$1,250
1861 TYPE 2 LIBERTY HEAD $2.5 QUARTER EAGLE GOLD PCGS AU58 Trader Bea
$950
1911 S $10 INDIAN GOLD EAGLE NGC AU 58 * RARE SAN FRANCISCO! 51K POP 154/128
$4,499
1906 $10 Gold Eagle PCGS AU58 Circulated Business Strike Philadelphia Mint Coin
$2,400
1853 US Coronet Head Quarter Eagle $2.50 Gold Coin - Choice About UNC, PCGS AU58
$856
1914-D $2.50 Indian Gold Quarter Eagle PCGS AU58 Denver Business Strike Coin
$775
1908 US Liberty Head $5 Dollar Gold Eagle Coin ICG AU58 Philadelphia .900 Fine
$1,360
1913-S Indian Gold Eagle $10 Coin - Certified NGC AU58 - Rare - $4,750 Value
$3,599
NGC AU58 1909-D Indian $5 Gold Eagle 0.2419 Oz Gold US Coin 8368547-003
$1,473
1897-O Liberty Head Gold Eagle $10 Coin PCGS AU58 Nice Eye Appeal
$2,703
1838 Classic Gold Quarter Eagle $2.50 Coin - Certified NGC AU58 - Rare Date!
$3,406
1913-S Indian Gold Half Eagle $5 Coin - Certified PCGS AU58 - Cracked Holder
$1,506
1913-S Indian Gold Eagle $10 Coin - Certified PCGS AU58 - Rare - $4,750 Value
$4,308
1835 Classic Head Gold Half Eagle $5 RARE Early Gold Coin- NGC graded AU58+ Plus
$4,250
1882-O $10 Liberty Head Gold Eagle NGC Graded AU58 New Orleans Coin NR #C828-2
$6,544
1914 $10 Gold Eagle Indian Head PCGS AU58 Gold Shield
$2,600
US 1836 P $5.00 Gold Classic Head PCGS AU 58 Half Eagle Coin
$2,776
1911 $10 Gold Eagle Indian Head PCGS AU58 Gold Shield
$2,600
1909-S Indian Gold Half Eagle $5 Coin - PCGS AU58 - Rare Date - $2,250 Value
$1,696
12
Next

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is American Gold Eagle AU58 worth?
The average sold price for American Gold Eagle AU58 is $2,136, with a median of $1,700. Prices range from $715 to $6,544 based on 28 eBay sold listings.
What is the average price of American Gold Eagle AU58?
American Gold Eagle AU58 sells for an average of $2,136 on eBay. The median price is $1,700, which better represents typical sales by filtering out outliers.
What is the most expensive American Gold Eagle AU58 ever sold?
The highest recorded sale for American Gold Eagle AU58 on eBay is $6,544. The lowest sale is $715. Data is based on 28 completed eBay transactions.
Source: SoldPriceGuide (soldpriceguide.com) — eBay sold listing data, regularly updated. Last updated: June 2026.