Buffalo Nickel AU58 Sold Prices
The median sold price for Buffalo Nickel AU58 is $80.00. Most sell between $25.99 and $750, based on 191 eBay sold listings.
Median Price
The middle price when all sales are sorted. Best represents what most buyers pay.
$80.00
Avg Price
The mean of the middle 80% of sold prices. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$149
Most Sell For
80% of sales fall within this range. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$25.99 – $750
10th–90th percentile
Total Sales
191
Price History
$324$165
$291
2026-01
28 sales
$207
2026-02
56 sales
$165
2026-03
43 sales
$324
2026-04
43 sales
$292
2026-05
19 sales
2026-012026-05
| Month | Average price | Sales |
|---|---|---|
| 2026-01 | $291 | 28 |
| 2026-02 | $207 | 56 |
| 2026-03 | $165 | 43 |
| 2026-04 | $324 | 43 |
| 2026-05 | $292 | 19 |
Price Distribution
<$26
18 sales
$26–$130
102 sales
$130–$230
22 sales
$230–$340
12 sales
$340–$440
8 sales
$440–$540
5 sales
$540–$650
1 sales
$650–$750
2 sales
>$750
21 sales
<$26$340–$440>$750
| Price range | Sales |
|---|---|
| <$26 | 18 |
| $26–$130 | 102 |
| $130–$230 | 22 |
| $230–$340 | 12 |
| $340–$440 | 8 |
| $440–$540 | 5 |
| $540–$650 | 1 |
| $650–$750 | 2 |
| >$750 | 21 |
Sales
Showing 76–100 of 191
Sort:
| Title | Coin Type | Grade | Year | Price | Sold | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | 1937 Indian Head Buffalo Nickel AU58 ICG *2049 Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1937 | $21.95 | Mar 22, 2026 |
 | 1937-D Indian Head Buffalo Nickel AU58 ICG Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1937 | $27.00 | Mar 22, 2026 |
 | 1938-D PCGS AU58 Choice AU+ Buffalo Nickel - Spectacular Colorful Toned! Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1938 | $250 | Mar 21, 2026 |
 | 1923 5 Cent Buffalo Nickel US Mint NGC AU58 Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1923 | $128 | Mar 21, 2026 |
 | 1916 Buffalo Nickel - 5c PCGS AU58 - PCGS Gold Shield Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1916 | $79.99 | Mar 21, 2026 |
 | 1937-S Buffalo Nickel — PCGS AU58 Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1937 | $40.00 | Mar 18, 2026 |
 | 1935 P NGC AU58 Buffalo Nickel 5c Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1935 | $35.00 | Mar 18, 2026 |
 | 1936 Buffalo Nickel FS-018.7 DDO PCGS AU58 Slider - Doubled Die Obverse Variety Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1936 | $300 | Mar 17, 2026 |
 | 1916 D Buffalo Nickel AU 58 NGC Graded Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1916 | $99.00 | Mar 16, 2026 |
 | 1935-S PCGS-AU58 BUFFALO NICKEL Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1935 | $60.00 | Mar 15, 2026 |
 | 1923 5C CAC AU58 Buffalo Nickel - Witterbrick, About Uncirculated Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1923 | $75.00 | Mar 15, 2026 |
 | 1916 D Buffalo Nickel 5C PCGS AU58 - 25188 Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1916 | $195 | Mar 14, 2026 |
 | 1938 D/S OMM-1 Buffalo Nickel 5c ANACS AU 58 Old Soapbox Holder Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1938 | $45.02 | Mar 12, 2026 |
 | 1936 5C Buffalo Nickel ANACS AU58 - Lovely Dual Sided Peripheral Toning Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1936 | $180 | Mar 12, 2026 |
 | 1935 S BUFFALO NICKEL ANACS AU 58 760 Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1935 | $36.00 | Mar 10, 2026 |
 | 1936 BUFFALO NICKEL ANACS AU 58 771 Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1936 | $23.00 | Mar 10, 2026 |
 | 1916-P Buffalo Nickel 5c PCGS AU58 Some Toning Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1916 | $79.00 | Mar 10, 2026 |
 | 1918 "D" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC AU58 #002 About Unc ECC&C, Inc. Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1918 | $95.00 | Mar 10, 2026 |
 | 1927-P Buffalo Nickel PCGS AU58 TONER Superb Eye Appeal Nice Strike Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1927 | $172 | Mar 9, 2026 |
 | 1934-D AU 58 Buffalo Nickel PCGS Tougher Thirties Date PPQ Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1934 | $104 | Mar 9, 2026 |
 | 1917 Buffalo Nickel 5C PCGS AU58~Very Nice! Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1917 | $60.00 | Mar 8, 2026 |
 | 1921 ~ Buffalo 5c ~ PCGS AU58 ~ Looks MS62 ~ Great Luster & Color ~ SLIDER ~ NEW Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1921 | $154 | Mar 8, 2026 |
 | 1923 Buffalo Nickel CAC AU58 Certified 5C Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1923 | $44.00 | Mar 8, 2026 |
 | 1916-D BUFFALO NICKEL NGC AU58 683024 Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1916 | $155 | Mar 7, 2026 |
 | 1930 NGC AU58 DDR FS-801 (5-Legged Buffalo) Buffalo Nickel-Price Guide $375 Buffalo Nickel · AU58 | Buffalo Nickel | AU58 | 1930 | $315 | Mar 6, 2026 |
Frequently Asked Questions
- How much is Buffalo Nickel AU58 worth?
- The average sold price for Buffalo Nickel AU58 is $149, with a median of $80.00. Prices range from $13.50 to $3,500 based on 191 eBay sold listings.
- What is the average price of Buffalo Nickel AU58?
- Buffalo Nickel AU58 sells for an average of $149 on eBay. The median price is $80.00, which better represents typical sales by filtering out outliers.
- What is the most expensive Buffalo Nickel AU58 ever sold?
- The highest recorded sale for Buffalo Nickel AU58 on eBay is $3,500. The lowest sale is $13.50. Data is based on 191 completed eBay transactions.
Source: SoldPriceGuide (soldpriceguide.com) — eBay sold listing data, regularly updated. Last updated: June 2026.