Skip to content

Buffalo Nickel MS65 Sold Prices

The median sold price for Buffalo Nickel MS65 is $110. Most sell between $55.00 and $425, based on 676 eBay sold listings.

Median Price
The middle price when all sales are sorted. Best represents what most buyers pay.
$110
Avg Price
The mean of the middle 80% of sold prices. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$148
Most Sell For
80% of sales fall within this range. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$55.00 – $425
10th–90th percentile
Total Sales
676

Price History

$266$58.50
$58.50
2025-12
2 sales
$184
2026-01
129 sales
$196
2026-02
159 sales
$218
2026-03
143 sales
$266
2026-04
138 sales
$156
2026-05
95 sales
2025-122026-05
Monthly average price history
MonthAverage priceSales
2025-12$58.502
2026-01$184129
2026-02$196159
2026-03$218143
2026-04$266138
2026-05$15695

Price Distribution

<$55
65 sales
$55–$110
270 sales
$110–$160
95 sales
$160–$210
61 sales
$210–$270
39 sales
$270–$320
34 sales
$320–$370
23 sales
$370–$430
20 sales
>$430
69 sales
<$55$210–$270>$430
Price distribution by bucket
Price rangeSales
<$5565
$55–$110270
$110–$16095
$160–$21061
$210–$27039
$270–$32034
$320–$37023
$370–$43020
>$43069

Sales

Showing 451–475 of 676

Sort:
NewestPrice HighPrice LowOldest
TitlePrice
1938-D 5C Buffalo Nickel - NGC fatty old holder MS 65
$82.00
1936 5C Buffalo Nickel - PCGS old holder MS 65
$81.00
1936 5C Buffalo Nickel - PCGS old holder MS 65
$96.00
1937-D Buffalo Nickel 5c - PCGS MS65 - Old Holder
$56.00
1938-D 5C Buffalo Nickel - PCGS old holder MS 65
$91.00
1938-D 5C Buffalo Nickel - PCGS old holder MS 65
$91.00
1936-D PCGS MS65 Gem BU Buffalo Nickel- Lustrous and Original, Nicely Toned!
$95.00
1937 D Indian Head Buffalo Nickel MS 65 NGC Bag Fragment SKU:I22646
$71.99
1921-S Buffalo PCGS MS 65+
1921-S Buffalo PCGS MS 65+
Buffalo Nickel · MS65
$14,934
unusual price
1937 Buffalo Nickel 5C CAC MS 65
1937 Buffalo Nickel 5C CAC MS 65
Buffalo Nickel · MS65
$53.00
1937-D Buffalo Nickel Ms 65 PCGS Old Holder
$104
1935 Buffalo Nickel NGC MS 65 – Gem BU –
$81.00
1938 "D/S" Indian Head BUFFALO Nickel 5c NGC MS65 #068 Gem BU Unc ECC&C, Inc.
$115
💎 1926 Buffalo 5c Nickel ☆ PCGS MS 65 ☆ Gold Shield - Beautiful Gem Coin! SLB26
$232
1913 Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 CAC Type 1
$259
1936-D Buffalo Nickel ✦ PCGS Certified MS65 ✦ Premium Gem
$98.00
1937-S Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65 Old Holder
$65.00
1937-D 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS MS65
$78.99
1938-D PCGS MS65 Gem BU Buffalo Nickel - Beautiful Pastel Color Toned!
$66.00
1938-D NGC MS65 Buffalo Nickel!
1938-D NGC MS65 Buffalo Nickel!
Buffalo Nickel · MS65
$41.00
1916 Buffalo PCGS (CAC) MS 65
1916 Buffalo PCGS (CAC) MS 65
Buffalo Nickel · MS65
$536
1938-D Buffalo Nickel NGC MS65
1938-D Buffalo Nickel NGC MS65
Buffalo Nickel · MS65
$68.95
1913 5C NGC MS65 TYPE 1 BUFFALO "MINT ERROR" ~ EXCEPTIONAL PQ GEM!
$239
1938-D/S BUFFALO NICKEL - PCGS MS-65
$125
1938-D Buffalo Nickel, NGC MS 65, Early Generation 3 Holder, Embossed Reverse.
$114
Previous
1718192021
Next

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is Buffalo Nickel MS65 worth?
The average sold price for Buffalo Nickel MS65 is $148, with a median of $110. Prices range from $19.99 to $14,934 based on 676 eBay sold listings.
What is the average price of Buffalo Nickel MS65?
Buffalo Nickel MS65 sells for an average of $148 on eBay. The median price is $110, which better represents typical sales by filtering out outliers.
What is the most expensive Buffalo Nickel MS65 ever sold?
The highest recorded sale for Buffalo Nickel MS65 on eBay is $14,934. The lowest sale is $19.99. Data is based on 676 completed eBay transactions.
Source: SoldPriceGuide (soldpriceguide.com) — eBay sold listing data, regularly updated. Last updated: June 2026.