Skip to content

Buffalo Nickel Proof Sold Prices

The median sold price for Buffalo Nickel Proof is $70.00. Most sell between $3.99 and $800, based on 30 eBay sold listings.

Median Price
The middle price when all sales are sorted. Best represents what most buyers pay.
$70.00
Avg Price
The mean of the middle 80% of sold prices. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$215
Most Sell For
80% of sales fall within this range. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$3.99 – $800
10th–90th percentile
Total Sales
30

Price History

$393$114
$269
2026-01
9 sales
$114
2026-02
9 sales
$393
2026-03
10 sales
2026-012026-03
Monthly average price history
MonthAverage priceSales
2026-01$2699
2026-02$1149
2026-03$39310

Price Distribution

<$4
2 sales
$4–$120
16 sales
$120–$230
3 sales
$350–$460
1 sales
$690–$800
4 sales
>$800
4 sales
<$4$350–$460>$800
Price distribution by bucket
Price rangeSales
<$42
$4–$12016
$120–$2303
$230–$3500
$350–$4601
$460–$5700
$570–$6900
$690–$8004
>$8004

Sales

Showing 1–25 of 30

Sort:
NewestPrice HighPrice LowOldest
TitlePrice
24kt Gold Plated Buffalo Nickels No-Date Proof Finish Amazing Shine Great Gift
$3.65
1937 Buffalo Nickel * Choice Proof * Rare - Key Date * XXB855
$800
1937 Buffalo Nickel ~ Gem BU++ Proof Like PL ~ ZB194
$75.98
1936 US "Brilliant" PROOF Buffalo Nickel! Very Low Mintage of 4,420! SCARCE!
$770
1915 Buffalo Nickel BU *SATIN PROOF-LIKE FEATURES* READ MORE
$150
HARDER TONED 1913 TY 2 BUFFALO 5c, 37 Mercury 90% 10c, 68 Kennedy Proof 40% 50c
$44.75
1936 Buffalo Nickel * Choice Proof * Rare - Key Date * XXB444
$1,000
1936 Brilliant PROOF Buffalo Nickel 5C PCGS Genuine PR
$891
1913 t2 buffalo nickel Very Proof Like Fields
$45.00
1913 T1Raised Ground buffalo nickel proof strike? VF Condition, Toner see pics
$150
VINTAGE United States Coin Lot of 19 Buffalo Nickel And proof.
$12.00
1936 5C Type 2 Brilliant Proof Buffalo Nickel DDR 3 Legged Error Coin
$42.00
1937 Buffalo Nickel ~ Gem BU++ Proof Like PL ~ ZB121
$79.98
Early US Nickel Lot – Liberty V, Buffalo, Silver War, Proofs 1899–1964
$26.00
1937 Buffalo Nickel * Choice Proof * Rare - Key Date * XXB808
$800
MINIATURE COIN 1913 BUFFALO NICKEL PROOF LIKE CUPRO NICKEL
$20.00
US Mint Silver JFK 40%. A Proof Set. IKE Dollar. Buffalo Nickel. V Nickel. Dime
$16.50
1961 - P Jefferson Nickel 5c Coin - Proof From Proof Set
$1.50
RARE BUFFALO NICKEL 1877 INDIAN HEAD PROOF 4 COIN SET PURE COPPER .999 TROY OZ
$24.44
1936 PCGS Satin PROOF Buffalo Nickel
$800
RARE BUFFALO NICKEL PROOF 3 COIN SET PURE COPPER BULLION .999 TROY OUNCE
$19.36
Shiny 1991 Proof Set
Shiny 1991 Proof Set
Buffalo Nickel · Proof
$3.99
Shiny 1985 Proof Set, nickel has CRISP FULL STEPS
$4.99
2020 SILVER PROOF SET NGC "FIRST DAY OF ISSUE" SEALED AND LABELS
$160
2005 Buffalo Nickel Giant Quarter Pound Silver Proof, Low Serial # 026
$370
12
Next
Source: SoldPriceGuide (soldpriceguide.com) — eBay sold listing data, updated daily. Last updated: April 2026.