Skip to content

Buffalo Nickel XF40 Sold Prices

The median sold price for Buffalo Nickel XF40 is $250. Most sell between $59.88 and $1,195, based on 45 eBay sold listings.

Median Price
The middle price when all sales are sorted. Best represents what most buyers pay.
$250
Avg Price
The mean of the middle 80% of sold prices. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$426
Most Sell For
80% of sales fall within this range. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$59.88 – $1,195
10th–90th percentile
Total Sales
45

Price History

$641$375
$641
2026-01
7 sales
$399
2026-02
8 sales
$636
2026-03
22 sales
$375
2026-04
8 sales
2026-012026-04
Monthly average price history
MonthAverage priceSales
2026-01$6417
2026-02$3998
2026-03$63622
2026-04$3758

Price Distribution

<$60
4 sales
$60–$220
13 sales
$220–$380
10 sales
$380–$550
3 sales
$550–$710
3 sales
$710–$870
2 sales
$870–$1k
2 sales
$1k–$1.2k
3 sales
>$1.2k
5 sales
<$60$550–$710>$1.2k
Price distribution by bucket
Price rangeSales
<$604
$60–$22013
$220–$38010
$380–$5503
$550–$7103
$710–$8702
$870–$1k2
$1k–$1.2k3
>$1.2k5

Sales

Showing 26–45 of 45

Sort:
NewestPrice HighPrice LowOldest
TitlePrice
1914-D .05 PCGS XF40 Buffalo Nickel, Indian Nickel, 5 Cent Piece
$280
1917-D Buffalo Nickel NGC XF-40 - Excellent Surfaces!
$193
1936 P Buffalo Nickel 5c CAC XF40 Nice Luster
$65.00
1937 D 3 Legs PCGS XF 40 Buffalo Nickel, Scarce Three Legged, Error Type Coin
$976
1915-S PCGS XF40 Buffalo Nickel 5c - San Francisco Mint
$475
1919 D BUFFALO NICKEL NGC XF40
1919 D BUFFALO NICKEL NGC XF40
Buffalo Nickel · XF40
$265
1934-D NGC XF 40 U.S. Mint Buffalo Nickel **Great Eye Appeal** 84-011
$39.95
1925 S NGC XF40 Buffalo Nickel
1925 S NGC XF40 Buffalo Nickel
Buffalo Nickel · XF40
$223
1924-D ~ Buffalo Nickel ~ PCGS XF40 ~ ORIGINAL ~ Great Antique Toning ~ NEW
$195
1927-D Buffalo Nickel PCGS#3961 XF40 Excellent overall original sharpness
$99.00
1921-S Buffalo Nickel NGC XF40 KEY DATE
$675
1923 S Buffalo Nickels 5C PCGS XF40 53982163
$246
1937-D 5C Buffalo Nickel 3 Legs Legged XF-40 PCGS/CAC, Very Orignal Coin!
$1,450
1937-D 3-Legged Buffalo Nickel CERTIFIED NGC XF 40 5c
$1,200
1926 S Buffalo Nickel Graded PCGS XF40 Stunning Key Date Coin (Slab1363)
$870
1929 S Buffalo Nickel PCGS XF 40 - *DoubleJCoins* JL1100-410
$65.00
1937-D 5c Buffalo Nickel ~ PCGS XF40 - 3 Legs
$1,155
1930-P 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS XF40 BB8578
$27.00
1913 Variety 2 Indian Head or Buffalo Nickel ANACS : XF40 : TYPE TWO
$59.88
1937-D 3 Legs 5C Buffalo Nickel PCGS XF-40
$1,113
Previous
12
Source: SoldPriceGuide (soldpriceguide.com) — eBay sold listing data, updated daily. Last updated: April 2026.