Skip to content

McCoy cookie jar Sold Prices

The median sold price for McCoy cookie jar is $30.50. Most sell between $14.98 and $79.99, based on 337 eBay sold listings.

Median Price
The middle price when all sales are sorted. Best represents what most buyers pay.
$30.50
Avg Price
The mean of the middle 80% of sold prices. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$35.63
Most Sell For
80% of sales fall within this range. Excludes outliers at both ends.
$14.98 – $79.99
10th–90th percentile
Total Sales
337

Price History

$51.72$35.07
$36.42
2026-03
17 sales
$36.45
2026-04
30 sales
$47.63
2026-05
23 sales
$35.07
2026-06
12 sales
$43.69
2026-07
78 sales
$44.35
2026-08
65 sales
$51.72
2026-09
13 sales
2026-032026-09
Monthly average price history
MonthAverage priceSales
2026-03$36.4217
2026-04$36.4530
2026-05$47.6323
2026-06$35.0712
2026-07$43.6978
2026-08$44.3565
2026-09$51.7213

Price Distribution

<$15
33 sales
$15–$24
82 sales
$24–$34
64 sales
$34–$43
43 sales
$43–$52
35 sales
$52–$61
19 sales
$61–$71
16 sales
$71–$80
9 sales
>$80
36 sales
<$15$43–$52>$80
Price distribution by bucket
Price rangeSales
<$1533
$15–$2482
$24–$3464
$34–$4343
$43–$5235
$52–$6119
$61–$7116
$71–$809
>$8036

Sales

Showing 1–25 of 337

Sort:
TitlePrice
Vintage McCoy Pottery Stove Cookie Jar White Gold Kitchen Range USA
$22.50
Vintage McCoy Pottery Yellow Apple Cookie Jar Collectible Mid Century Hand paint
$55.00
Vintage 50’s BRUSH MCCOY Baby Elephant Cookie Jar w/ice cream cone, Pastel 12”
$64.99
Vintage pottery Made in the USA McCoy Cookie Jar Bronze look shaped like tea pot
$14.99
Unmarked McCoy Pottery Nursery Rhyme Mary Mary Quite Contrary Cookie Jar
$60.00
Rare Vintage McCoy Cookie Jar Kittens Basket USA Pottery Cat Lid 1940s
$150
MINT Vintage McCoy Pottery Wishing Well Cookie Jar 1961 Wish I Had A Cookie USA
$63.75
Vintage McCoy Pottery Strawberry Pepper Cookie Jar Lid ONLY Green Ceramic USA
$28.99
VTG McCoy Cookie Jar “Have A Happy Day” Smiley FaceUSA Pottery Yellow
$73.00
McCoy Jojo The Clown Cookie Jar
$22.99
Vintage McCoy Pottery USA Egg In A Basket Cookie Jar & Lid Marked No. 0274
$50.00
Ceramic Pottery Lunch Pail Cookie Jar - Vintage
$21.20
Vintage McCoy Pottery Strawberry Cookie Jar #263 Red Green Ceramic USA 1950's
$45.00
Vintage Brush McCoy W-29 HUMPTY DUMPTY Pottery Cookie Jar
$130
Vintage McCoy USA Art Pottery Porcelain Cream and White Wedding Cake Cookie Jar
$12.25
Vtg. 1970s McCoy Pottery USA Thinking Dog Hound Puppy Treat Cookie Jar #0272
$15.00
McCoy Vintage Wishing Well Cookie Jar Wish I Had A Cookie USA Pottery MCM Brown
$28.00
Vintage LCC McCoy Pottery Big Red Apple Cookie Jar 1970s
$35.00
Vtg McCoy Pottery USA Alpo Dog Biscuit Treat Cookie Jar Dan the Dog Livasnaps
$30.00
Vtg 1970s McCoy Pink & Blue stripe Canister/Cookie jar #135M, 9” tall
$37.00
Vintage Wishing Well Cookie Jar McCoy “I Wish I Had a Cookie"
$40.00
Vintage 1967 McCoy Pottery "Coalby" Black Cat Cookie Jar #207
$280
Vintage McCoy Pottery Coffee Cup Cookie Jar
$19.00
1950s McCoy Indian Head Cookie Jar W/ Lid
$68.00
1950's Vintage McCoy Burgundy Strawberry Cookie Jar Lid USA Pottery
$70.00

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is McCoy cookie jar worth?
The average sold price for McCoy cookie jar is $35.63, with a median of $30.50. Prices range from $4.95 to $350 based on 337 eBay sold listings.
What is the average price of McCoy cookie jar?
McCoy cookie jar sells for an average of $35.63 on eBay. The median price is $30.50, which better represents typical sales by filtering out outliers.
What is the most expensive McCoy cookie jar ever sold?
The highest recorded sale for McCoy cookie jar on eBay is $350. The lowest sale is $4.95. Data is based on 337 completed eBay transactions.
Source: SoldPriceGuide (soldpriceguide.com) — eBay sold listing data, regularly updated. Last updated: September 2026.